V = Vegan / VGF = VeganGlutenFree

Now accepting online orders with a 5-day notice for pickup at any of our 3 locations!

Order Online

If you have an order that is detailed or need something quicker than 5 days, please call the store at (732) 217-1750! We would be happy to accommodate you! :)

$2.75 V / $3.25 VGF
Baby Biscotti
$2.25 V / $2.50 VGF

Bars & Brownies

$5.00 V / VGF Regular
$3.50 V / $3.75 VGF Mini

Cheesecake Cups & Cakes
$5.00 Cheesecake Cup VGF
$65.00 6-inch VGF
$95.00 10-inch VGF


Loaves & Muffins
8-inch Loaf $25.00 V / $30.00 VGF
Mini Loaf $7.50 V / $8.00 VGF
Mini Muffins $2.25 V / $2.50 VGF
Muffins $4.50 V / $5.00 VGF

9-inch $35.00 V / $42.00 VGF

Specialty Items

Apple Pie Pizza
Slice $8.50 V
14-inch (8 slices) $65 V
Babka (Chocolate) $6.50 V
Cake Pops $4.00 V / $4.00 VGF
Chocolate Pot de Creme / Tres Leches in a baby Ball jar $6.00 VGF
Cinnamon Buns $5.00 V / $5.00 VGF
Cookie Dough Tub $12 V / $13 VGF
  • Almond $7.50 V
  • Chocolate $6.50 V
  • Everything $5.00 V
  • Plain $5.00 V
Crumb Cake $5.00 V / $5.00 VGF
  • Baked $4.00 V / VGF
Mini Bundt Cake $8.00 V / $8.50 VGF
Monkey Bread / Sticky Buns $5.00 V
Whoopie Pie $5.00 V / $6.00 VGF
Yodel $6.00 VGF

Food Glorious Food

Everything Bagels $3.50 VGF
  • Available Friday, Saturday, Sunday, and Holidays
Chicken Ranch Wrap $14.50 V
Eggplant Parmesan Stromboli $14.00 V
Eggplant Parmesan Tray $14.50 VGF
Mac n’ Cheese $13.50 V / $15.00 VGF
Penne Vodka $13.50 V / $15.00 VGF
Soup $8.50 print VGF
Stuffed Riceballs $5.00 VGF
12-inch $65 VGF

Papa Ganache Cakes

4-inch (serves 1-2) $25 V / $30 VGF
6-inch (serves 6-10) $50 V / $55 VGF
9-inch (serves 15-20) $75 V / $85 VGF
12-inch (serves 35-40) $135 V / $155 VGF
14-inch (serves 50) $185 V / $210 VGF
Half Sheet (serves 65) $250 V / $275 VGF
Black & White

Vanilla cake with chocolate frosting inside and out


Carrot cake filled with cream cheese frosting or vanilla frosting

Chocolate Obsession

Chocolate cake, chocolate frosting, ganache drizzle & chocolate chips

Cookies n’ Cream

Chocolate cake with cookies n’ cream frosting, double chocolate cookies

Crème Brûlée

Vanilla cake with pastry cream, crème brûlée frosting, torched raw sugar


Chocolate cake with vanilla filling, covered in chocolate ganache, vanilla swirls

Naked Boston Crème

Vanilla cake filled with pastry cream, vanilla buttercream, chocolate ganache

Naked Cake

Chocolate or vanilla cake, naked crumbcoat

Naked Brownie

Chocolate brownie layered with chocolate buttercream, topped with ganache

Red Velvet

Red velvet cake with cream cheese OR vanilla frosting, ganache drizzle, red velvet cake crumbs

S’mores Cake

Chocolate cake with vanilla buttercream, drizzled in chocolate ganache, toasted marshmallows, graham cracker crumbs

Very Vanilla

Vanilla cake with vanilla frosting

Papa Ganache Specialty Cakes

Inquire about pricing or Order Online

Brownie Mountain

Brownie cake with chocolate frosting topped a mountain of brownies, chocolate chip cookie crumbles, & chocolate chips

Chocolate Mousse

Chocolate cake filled with chocolate mousse, chocolate frosting, chocolate cake crumbs

Naked Chocolate Peanut Butter Cup

Chocolate cake with peanut butter frosting, chocolate ganache, chopped peanuts, house-made peanut butter cups

Cookie Monster / Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough Cake

Vanilla cake baked with chocolate chip cookie dough, vanilla frosting, chocolate chip cookie crumbles. Decorated as Cookie Monster.

Not A Monster / Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough Cake

Vanilla cake baked with chocolate chip cookie dough, vanilla frosting, chocolate chip cookie crumbles

Donut Cake

Vanilla or chocolate cake with ombre frosting, white chocolate ganache, topped with frosted baked donuts (choice of colors)


Vanilla cake baked with sprinkles, vanilla frosting & more sprinkles (choice of color)

Kathy’s Naked Cake

Chocolate cake with fresh raspberries & preserves, fresh flora whipped cream, chocolate ganache, topped with fresh glazed raspberries

Naked Apple Cobbler or Naked Blueberry Cobbler

Cinnamon cobbler cake with apple pie filling or fresh blueberry compote, cinnamon frosting, apple compote or blueberry, topped with streusel

Naked Lemon Curd

Lemon cake filled with lemon curd & lemon frosting

Naked Rainbow Cookie

Almond flavored tri-color cake filled with raspberry preserves, raspberry frosting, drenched in chocolate ganache, rainbow cookies

Naked Strawberries & Cream

Vanilla cake, Tres Leches strawberry cream, fresh strawberries

Naked Tiramisu

Vanilla cake soaked in coffee, house-made mascarpone mousse, chocolate ganache, topped with coffee buttercream

Naked Tres Leches with Mixed Berries

Vanilla cake soaked in almond, cashew, and coconut milks, tres leches whip, mixed berries


Vanilla or chocolate cake, rosette flowers covering the cake

Ombre Rosettes

Vanilla or chocolate cake, ombre icing, rosette flowers covering the cake (choice of color)

Strawberry Shortcake

Vanilla cake filled with fresh strawberries on vanilla icing, vanilla frosting, topped with fresh strawberries

Chocolate Strawberry Shortcake

Chocolate cake filled with fresh strawberries on vanilla icing, vanilla frosting, drenched in chocolate ganache & topped with fresh chocolate-dipped strawberries

All items and flavors listed are not always available in-store.

Special Orders
All items other than cakes and pies have a six-piece minimum per item/per flavor
Cookies are 12 pieces minimum per flavor.

All products are 100% Vegan
All VeganGlutenFree products are produced in a dedicated VeganGlutenFree kitchen
Items containing nuts & soy are produced on shared equipment
Papa Ganache is NOT a nut-free facility

Pictures are for reference only. Bakers take a creative license on all items. If you want an item exactly as pictured, you are required to indicate when ordering.

Want a custom cake?

We would be happy to discuss a special order or event with you. Please send your ideas, thoughts, or photos to Lisa at [email protected] with the following info:
> How many servings
> Vegan or VeganGlutenFree
> Allergens
> Cake flavor
Upcharge for additional fillings, layers, fresh fruit, icing & fondant decorations. Pricing for larger cakes that endure upcharges for additional features, fillings, etc., are available by contacting Lisa at [email protected] - thanks!